Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Water crisis looming Malaysia: By Dr. Vikneswaran Nair

Your article, “Asia faces worsening water crisis” (The Star, Oct 13, 2010) is referred. I truly hope the article will ring some ‘alarm-bells’ in Malaysia.

Indeed Asia is facing a worsening water crisis that will severely impact food production especially with the rising population. The population of Asia has increased over the past decade on the same trend as the global population which has tripled in the 20th century but water consumption went up sevenfold. Sadly, the technology to increase water production has been stagnant over the past decade. Developing new water resources are increasingly expensive to develop.

Hence, the only solution to sustain the need of the current population and for the generations to come is to conserve and to control the overzealous deforestation that is wiping out the very resources that is required to generate water. It is alarming to note from the report of the Asia Development Bank that the water footprint in our towns and cities, in our irrigation systems, our energy production systems and in industry in general is extravagant. As populations grow and water use per person rises, demand for freshwater is soaring. Yet the supply of freshwater is finite and threatened by pollution. Agenda 21 of the Rio Declaration 1992 states that effectively integrated management of water resources is important to all socio-economic sectors.

Your article early this year on, “Global crisis of water scarcity” (The Star, March 1, 2010) reporte

d that a decade ago, it was predicted that a third of the world’s population would be facing water scarcity by 2025. Unfortunately, this threshold has already been reached. Today two billion people live in countries that are water-stressed and by 2025, two-thirds of the world population may suffer water stress, unless current trends alter.

Over here in Malaysia, we need to ring this ‘alarm-bells’ as well. There are already signs that are showing the catastrophe that Malaysia is heading if various stakeholders do not do their part to manage the water efficiently. This includes the mass population of the country. We need to stop wasting so much of the water.

Water resource demand has surpassed sustainable levels of supply in many areas as unbalanced economic development continues to degrade the water quality and the natural environment. Despite the well laid out plan in the Ninth Malaysia Plan in rehabilitation and modernisation of water supply systems, water resources development, water treatment and distribution and inter-state raw water transfer, the problem of water shortage in the country still remain at the critical level.

Malaysia is tropical and lush with enough water for its needs on an annual basis but tap water shortages still occur and water cuts are part of everyday life. The bottom line is people do not want to suffer a repeat of the 1998 crisis, which forced many hotels, restaurants and laundries to close down.

There has also been large amount of unplanned and unsustainable development in the highland forests in Malaysia, including inappropriate road building and excessive highland resort development. Excessive clearing of forests has led to the siltation of rivers and contamination of the water supply. Forest clearance has resulted in frequent occurrences of soil erosion and landslides. The quality of water gradually deteriorates due to siltation and pollution from the construction work of the highland roads, while poorly constructed roads contribute to soil erosion and water pollution.

It is amazing that in a country with high rainfall like Malaysia we maybe hit with severe water shortage if we keep taking for granted that water is in abundance. Levels at the dams continue to fall. It is quite obvious that poor management of our water resources is one of the main reasons for the crisis. El Nino has had little to do with this.

The catchment areas no longer retain water, as they should. Many reasons can be cited, probably all arising from lack of coordination between the state agencies. While one agency designates the catchment areas as reserves, another approves logging concessions on them. Yet others allow the development of forest-depleting golf courses and quarrying in catchment areas. Industries with potential to contaminate rivers that feed reservoirs are allowed to operate upstream. It is time to take a hard look at the utilization of land in and around catchment areas and come up with a clear and sensible policy.

The generous use of drinking water and leakage in pipelines and taps are among the major causes of water wastage, amounting to millions of litres per day in Malaysia. The use of drinking water in gardening, car washing and toilet flushing also add to the wastage of drinking water. Brackish water or treated sewage water can be used as substitutes for potable water for these purposes. Another cause of the problem is the mishandling of wastewater from raw sewage, industrial waste, and agriculture runoffs, which increase the contamination in natural sources of fresh water. Sewerage water, therefore, ought not be allowed to fall into the sea or rivers, but should be treated properly, and stored outside the cities or villages to be supplied back to the residents for use. The recycling of sewerage water and its storage outside the cities will raise ground water levels, and the treated solid waste is a natural fertilizer. While recycling sewer water and its accumulation may create waterlogging in some areas and increase the salinity of the soil, in most cases it will raise the water level and result in fertile soil.

Waterlogging and salinity may be controlled through the use of modern scientific technology.

The water wastage in the urban is more significant than in the rural. Thus, an effective and efficient urban water management system that is able to reduce water loss and increase water-use efficiency is the way forward. Hence, in the short-term water restriction mechanism must be put in place while a long term water conservation plan is a must. Water pricing need to be reevaluated as we are taking for granted on this precious resources. The water use efficiency need to be improved while efficient water recycling and harvesting technology need to be supported and encouraged.

Over the past few years, the Malaysian environment has continued to deteriorate and will further deteriorate if all parties do not take this crisis serious. The rapid growth prior to the economic crisis and the present economic recovery, whilst raising the GNP and incomes, has had a toll on the environment. Uncontrolled growth with scant regard for ecological principles continues to be the order of the day. Education and enforcement are two vital approaches that must be used to change the mindset of the people. Only then can the understanding of essential link between polluted water resources, potable water, flood woes and good management can go hand in hand. The world needs to understand that at the pace we are wasting water today, the Third World War will be fought over water in this century. I certainly do not want to be in that generation when water becomes as precious as oil.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Vikneswaran Nair
Taylor’s University

Subang Jaya



Friday, October 1, 2010

Kenyir is doomed with DFZ idea: By Dr. Vikneswaran Nair

I am totally shocked and baffled with the news that Tasik Kenyir has been officially declared a Duty Free Zone(DFZ) as reported in “Kenyir is now a DFZ” (The Star, Sept 30, 2010). What is even baffling is the Finance Ministry has already officially endorsed this new status on Sept 21 as indicated by the Terengganu Menteri Besar.

After all the hue and cry over the closure of nine dive sites on the tropical islands of Tioman and Redang until the end of October (The Star, July 22, 2010), it was supposed to be a wake-up call for all stakeholders to play their part in an attempt to relieve stress on the fragile marine ecosystems in the coast of Terengganu. These popular dive sites in the South China Sea was hit by coral bleaching and the closure would give the coral a chance to regenerate and remove stress caused by tourism-related activities such as scuba diving and snorkeling.

But now, Kenyir, another popular eco-tourism site is being transformed into a DFZ. Why must an eco-tourism site that is meant to attract responsible eco-tourist be transformed into a mass tourism destination by making it a DFZ? It make no business and environmental sense to destroy the eco-system of Tasik Kenyir by transforming the destination with duty-free complex, shophouses, condominiums and Custom Department complex. Kenyir indeed has rich eco-system and bio-diversity with habitat to more than 8,000 species of flowers, 2,500 species of plants and trees as well as more than 300 species of freshwater fish. Carrying out an environmental impact assessment is not the easy solution for a project of this nature to be imported into a fragile environment like Kenyir.

When will Malaysia ever learn their lesson? In the recently presented Economic Transformation Programme (ETP), the tourism lab presentation highlighted the recognition and preservation of the bio-diversity in West and East Malaysia. And out of the blue, this totally contradictory plan is announced to transform an eco-destination to become shopping paradise. If this is part of the blueprint of the ETP in moving the country to achieve a high income nation by 2020, then sadly I am very disappointed with this new development.

Development of mega-resorts, hotels, condominiums, shopping malls and other duty-free complex in natural areas in the name of green tourism, eco-tourism or as a catalyst to attract mass tourist is indeed green-washing! Such mammoth artificially landscaped projects tend to irretrievably wipe out the flora and fauna and sometimes even totally vanishing the entire eco-system of Kenyir.

Malaysia is blessed with breathtaking islands along with white sandy beaches and clear waters, which generates significant tourism receipt for the nation. Tourism growth in Malaysia has been assisted, to an extent, by the abundant and rich coral reefs and shallow tropical marine resources in this region. By turning Kenyir into DFZ will result in the destination busting its carrying capacity and limit of acceptable change. Hence, it the long term, the largest man-made lake in South-East Asia will just remain in our memories with no chance for our future generations to enjoy the tranquility of this beautiful lake destination. The environment is the resource base for tourism; without protection, the natural attraction that brought the tourist to Kenyir in the first place will be lost.

Finally, I would like to urge the Terengganu State Government and the Finance Ministry to re-look into this idea of turning Kenyir into DFZ. Already, there are increased numbers' of visitors (eco-tourist) to almost all the marine park islands in Malaysia, as a result of increased promotion and green-washing done by various parties in the pretext of generating economic revenue. When demand rises, further development implemented in the areas that were previously untouched could cause extensive damage. Once destinations become popular, there is often no way to control development activities.